Victory for Voter Integrity: NY Court Strikes Down Noncitizen Voting Law

The controversial law that would have allowed noncitizens to vote in New York City elections was overturned by the state’s highest court on Thursday, marking a significant win for constitutional adherence and voter integrity.

Court’s Decisive Ruling

The New York Court of Appeals delivered a decisive 6-1 verdict against the law, which was initially passed by the City Council in late 2021. The court’s opinion clearly stated, “Whatever the future may bring, the New York Constitution as it stands today draws a firm line restricting voting to citizens.” This ruling reaffirms the constitutional requirement that voting rights are reserved for U.S. citizens.

Background of the Legislation

The law was championed by figures such as former Councilman Ydanis Rodriguez and had garnered significant support from Democratic members of the City Council, including Adrienne Adams and Brad Lander. Despite their efforts, the law was met with immediate legal challenges, preventing any noncitizen from casting a vote under its provisions.

Opposition was strong among Republicans who argued that the state constitution clearly restricted voting rights to U.S. citizens. Even progressive then-Mayor Bill de Blasio expressed reservations, choosing not to sign the bill, which then automatically became law under his successor, Eric Adams.

Republican Response and Legal Challenges

1776 Coalition Sponsored The Truth about Columbia University’s Moral Failure Columbia lost $400 Million in federal funding for good reason; they’ve been coddling up to America’s enemies. And the progressive left shouldn’t be so shocked because they’ve been helping to fund those antisemitic protests on college campuses. In fact, we have proof. Watch it here and then Stand with the Coalition for Jewish Values so we can rebuild America’s moral foundation.

Leading the charge against the law was Republican Staten Island Borough President Vito Fossella, who argued that it was unconstitutional and would undermine the value of votes cast by citizens. The legal challenge saw victories in lower courts before reaching the state’s highest court, which upheld the previous decisions.

Fossella celebrated the ruling, stating, “This is a victory for common sense, and the sanctity and security of our franchise — the right to vote as American citizens.” Assemblyman Michael Tannousis echoed this sentiment, emphasizing the importance of maintaining the integrity of the electoral process.

Implications of the Ruling

Rep. Nicole Malliotakis, a lead plaintiff in the lawsuit, expressed hope that the decision would deter left-wing lawmakers from introducing similar unconstitutional measures that could dilute the voices of American citizens. The ruling has been respected by the current administration, with Mayor Adams’ press secretary confirming there would be no appeal to the decision.

Continued Support for Citizen Voting

In light of the court’s decision, Republican mayoral candidate Curtis Sliwa highlighted the need to focus on increasing voter engagement among citizens, particularly in a city known for low voter turnout. Sliwa argued that efforts should be concentrated on making sure New Yorkers feel that their voices are heard and valued in the political process.

The ruling not only reaffirms the constitutional mandate that voting is a privilege of U.S. citizenship but also signals a commitment to upholding the principles of democracy and the rule of law in New York State.