ByÂ Daniel B. Wood and Gloria Goodale, Christian Science Monitor
The US Department of Justice filed suit against the state of Arizona in federal court Tuesday, challenging the state’s tough new immigration law requiring police to ask for ID from anyone they suspect of being undocumented.
The federal government will argue that federal law trumps the state statute and that enforcing immigration law is a federal responsibility. The Department has requested a preliminary injunction to delay enactment of the law, slated for July 29, arguing that the law’s operation will cause “irreparable harm.”
The DOJ’s lawsuit is based on theÂ preemption doctrineadopted by the Supreme Court under the Constitution’s supremacy clause, which states that certain matters are of such federal character, as opposed to local or state, that only the federal government can act on them.
As straightforward as that sounds, legal analysts are split over possible outcomes.
â€œI agree with the argument that the federal governmentâ€™s authority under the preemption clause will prevail over the Arizona state law,â€ says Robert Pugsley, professor of law at Southwestern Law School. â€œOtherwise we could have 50 states writing immigration laws and it would result in the chaos that the preemption clause was specifically created to prevent.â€
Likewise, Kevin Johnson, Dean of the School of Law at University of California, Davis, says, â€œ[we] have a clear situation where the federal government is having its powers intruded upon by the state government.â€
But that view does not necessarily mean the suit will succeed. â€œThere is good basis to believe the DOJ lawsuit may fail,” says Hector Chichoni, partner at the national law firm Epstein Becker Green. “The Arizona law does not necessarily preempt the Federal government, rather [it] sets the state and local government as enforcers of what is already available, and on certain cases, mandatory under immigration law.â€
Certain parts of the case are not black and white, including whether state police have authority to enforce federal immigration law, says Muzzafar Chisti, director of the Migration Policy Instituteâ€™s office at New York University School of Law.
Don’t let the MSM censor your news as America becomes Great Again. Over 500,000 Americans receive our daily dose of life, liberty and pursuit of happiness along with Breaking News direct to their inbox—and you can too. Sign up to receive news and views from The 1776Coalition!
We know how important your privacy is and your information is SAFE with us. We’ll never sell
your email address and you can unsubscribe at any time directly from your inbox.