Trump Administration’s Final Ultimatum to Maine on Transgender Athlete Policy

The Trump administration has sternly warned Maine that it must cease allowing individuals born male to compete in female sports categories, emphasizing the urgency by setting a deadline for compliance. Failure to adhere to this directive will prompt an investigation by the Justice Department, potentially leading to a withdrawal of federal funding.

Details of the Federal Warning

The Office for Civil Rights at the Department of Education has given the Maine Department of Education until April 11 to agree to a proposed resolution that would end the state’s violation of Title IX. This action follows a previous notification of noncompliance, which the state did not address, prompting this final warning.

Bradley Burke, OCR Regional Director, expressed his dissatisfaction with Maine’s lack of response, highlighting the state’s disregard for the protection and fair treatment of female athletes. Acting Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights, Craig Trainor, criticized the Maine Department of Education for its apparent indifference, stating that their actions allow male competitors to compromise the safety and recognition of female athletes.

Maine’s Resistance and the National Context

Maine Governor Janet Mills has opposed President Trump’s executive order to exclude male-born athletes from female sports, citing constitutional concerns and adherence to the rule of law. This stance is part of a broader disagreement with the Trump administration’s February decision to enforce Title IX based on biological sex, countering a previous Biden administration policy that recognized gender identity.

1776 Coalition Sponsored Don’t let Senate Republicans kill the Trump Agenda Why do Senate Republicans make the rest of the GOP worry every time Congress has a fight over major legislation? They rarely seem to remember that they were elected to protect individual rights, cut spending and limit government overreach. Fortunately, we have our Top Defenders of Liberty leading the way, like: Rand Paul, Mike Lee, and Ron Johnson. Unfortunately, there’s still many others in the U.S. Senate who earned a low score in our Liberty Index, and they need to hear from you. Will you join our efforts to ensure the U.S. Senate passes Trump’s “Big Beautiful Bill” without compromises or interference from Senate RINOS?

This conflict extends beyond the Department of Education, as the Department of Health and Human Services has also referred Maine to the Justice Department for similar reasons. The issue is far from theoretical in Maine, highlighted by recent events such as a male-born student winning a female state championship in pole vaulting.

Local Reactions and Legal Challenges

Maine School Administrative District #51 has refused to comply with a resolution agreement from HHS, citing the Maine Human Rights Act which prohibits discrimination based on gender identity. Additionally, the state is under scrutiny for allegedly concealing information about students’ gender transitions from their parents, a potential violation of the Family Educational Rights Privacy Act.

The controversy continues as numerous school districts in Maine implement “gender plans” for transitioning students, which they argue do not fall under the category of “educational records” and thus are not subject to parental notification under FERPA.

This ongoing dispute underscores a significant clash between state policies on gender identity and federal mandates aiming to protect the integrity of women’s sports, setting the stage for potential legal battles and further governmental intervention.