The U.S. Supreme Court’s Ketanji Brown Jackson expressed concern that the First Amendment “hamstrings the government in important ways, during the most critical time periods.”

Jackson spoke to Louisiana’s Solicitor-General Benjamin Aguinaga. His state, along with Missouri, has sued the federal government for its efforts to censor social media speech during the coronavirus epidemic, ostensibly out of public health concerns.

Jackson presented an earlier hypothetical scenario in which social media platforms allowed a dangerous trend in which children are encouraged to jump from windows “at increasingly higher elevations.” She then asked if government authorities couldn’t “encourage the social media platforms to remove the information which is causing this problem.”

Aguinaga said that the government can use its “bully pulpit”, to fight back against the information. However, it cannot call social media platforms and encourage or force them to remove the information.

1776 Coalition Sponsored Do you know why Winsome Sears matters? Bo Snerdley with New Journey, here with a dire warning. We could easily lose the Black voters who voted for Trump if we take them for granted like the Democrat Party did for nearly 70 years. If you want to see Black voters support America First Policies in 2025 and turn out for Republican candidates like Winsome Sears, then we need to start the work today.

Jackson argued that it wasn’t enough for the government to post its own speech. She suggested that the government might “encourage” or “require” this type of censorship for public safety in certain situations.

Conservatives objected when the White House called on social media companies not to share information, such as political speeches about election integrity or skepticism regarding vaccines.